Questions to ask a marketing agency before you sign anything

Most agency pitches sound alike: a strategy call, a deck with your logo on the cover, a monthly fee, and a note that the first quarter is about “learning.” The differences show up later, when you find out who is really working in the account, what you can take with you if you leave, and how the agency behaves in a slow month. The right questions to ask a marketing agency cost nothing, take about an hour, and surface those differences before you commit.

This checklist is grouped into the themes that decide whether the relationship works: the people, the process, ownership of your accounts and data, reporting, fees, what happens when results stall, exit terms, and what the agency needs from you. For each question you get what a good answer sounds like and what a warning sign sounds like.

Bring the list to the second conversation, after the pitch, when you are talking to the people who would actually run the work. The sales team is trained for the first call; the delivery team is where the truth lives.

Who actually does the work on your account

The person who sells the engagement and the person who runs it are rarely the same. Ask early, and ask by role and by name.

• Who will be in my ad accounts and website every week, and what is their experience in my industry? A good answer names roles and years: a paid search specialist with several years in home services, a content lead who has written for law firms, a coordinator who checks in weekly. A warning sign is “our team” with no names, or a senior founder on the sales call and a junior generalist on the delivery call.
• How many accounts does that specialist handle at once? A good answer is a number and a reason for it. A warning sign is a refusal to say, or a number so large that your account gets a few hours a month.
• Have you worked with a company like mine, and what did you learn that would change your plan for me? Industry experience matters less as a badge and more as a source of specifics: seasonality, lead quality problems, ad policies that apply to dentists or attorneys. A good answer includes a mistake they made once and would avoid now; a warning sign is a list of client names and nothing about the work itself.
• What happens if my specialist leaves the agency? A good answer describes documentation, a second person who already knows the account, and a hand-off period with overlap. A warning sign is “that never happens.”

If the agency subcontracts part of the work, that is not a problem on its own. Not telling you about it is. Ask directly whether any part of your scope goes to outside freelancers and who reviews their output.

How the process and communication will run

• What does the first 30 days look like, step by step? A good answer has dates and deliverables: access requests in the first days, a tracking audit, a written plan with priorities, a kickoff where targets are agreed, first changes live by a set date. A warning sign is “we start by learning your business” with nothing on a calendar.
• Who is my single point of contact, and how fast do they respond? A good answer is one named person, a stated response window (say one business day), and a fixed weekly or biweekly call. A warning sign is a shared inbox, or a different face on every call.
• How do you decide what goes live, and who approves it? A good answer draws a clear line: new campaigns, budget changes and anything customer-facing need your sign-off; bid adjustments, negative keywords and routine fixes do not. A warning sign is that everything needs your approval, which makes you the bottleneck, or that nothing does, which makes you the last to know.
• How do you handle urgent problems, like a disapproved ad or a tracking outage? A good answer includes monitoring, an escalation path and a person reachable during business hours. A warning sign is “just email us.”

Ask to see the tools that carry the process: the project board, the request form, the change log in the ad account. An agency that runs a real process can show it to you in five minutes, because it is already there.

Who owns the ad accounts, domains and analytics

This is the question owners skip and later regret. Your Google Ads account, Meta Business Manager, GA4 property, Search Console, domain registrar, email platform and CRM should sit in accounts your company owns, with the agency added as a user with the access it needs and nothing more.

• Will the ad accounts be created under my business, with my payment method, and will you be added as a manager? A good answer is yes, always, plus the access checklist they send on day one. A warning sign is “we run everything from our agency account, it is easier,” which means your history, your pixel data and your audiences leave when the agency does.
• Who owns the creative, the copy, the landing pages and the content you produce? A good answer: you do, once paid for, including source files and editable versions. A warning sign is usage rights that expire with the agreement.
• Where does the performance data live, and can I export it? A good answer points to your GA4 property and your CRM, exportable at any time. A warning sign is a proprietary dashboard as the only view of results.
• What access do you need from me, and how do you store it? A good answer is role-based access through the official manager tools, no shared passwords. A warning sign is a request for your login and password by email.

Write the ownership answers into the agreement itself. A verbal yes on a sales call is not a term you can rely on twelve months later.

How reporting and KPIs are agreed

• Which KPIs will you report, and which one will you be judged on? A good answer is one primary number per channel tied to leads or revenue (cost per qualified lead, return on ad spend, booked appointments), with supporting metrics explained as diagnostics. A warning sign is impressions, reach and “engagement” as the headline of the report. If you want a channel by channel view of what counts, marketing KPIs by channel lays it out.
• How will you set the first targets when there is no history? A good answer builds them from your unit economics (what a customer is worth, what share of leads close) and treats the first 90 days as a baseline to revise. A warning sign is industry benchmarks quoted as if they were your targets.
• What does the monthly report contain, and can I see a real one with another client's data removed? A good answer is a one-page summary, results against targets, spend by channel, what changed and why, and next month's plan; the structure is described in what a monthly marketing report should include. A warning sign is a dashboard screenshot with no commentary.
• Is conversion tracking verified before spend starts, and who checks it? A good answer makes the tracking audit the first deliverable and names the person responsible. A warning sign is “we optimize as we go.”

Ask one more thing: what will you not report, and why? An agency that has decided which numbers are noise has thought about your business.

How fees are separated from ad spend

You do not need amounts to judge this part; you need structure. The agency fee pays for people and process. Ad spend pays the platforms. The two should never be mixed in one line.

• Is ad spend billed to my card inside my own accounts, separate from your fee? A good answer is yes, with spend visible in the platform at all times. A warning sign is media bundled into one figure, which hides both the split and any markup.
• Is your fee flat or a percentage of spend, and why did you pick that model? A good answer explains the incentive either way: a percentage rewards growing the budget, a flat fee rewards efficiency, and a percentage should come with a cap or a floor. A warning sign is an uncapped percentage next to a plan that keeps recommending more budget.
• What is included in the fee, and what triggers an extra charge? A good answer is a written list: creative rounds, landing pages, calls, reporting, tools. A warning sign is “we will let you know when something is out of scope.”
• Which tools do I pay for directly, and which are yours? A good answer is a short list with a reason for each subscription. A warning sign is tools licensed to the agency that stop working the day you leave.
• When and how can the fee change? A good answer ties changes to scope changes you approve in writing. A warning sign is an automatic increase tied to your ad budget alone.

What happens when results stall

Every account has a flat quarter. The question is not whether it will happen, but what the agency does about it and how soon you hear.

• Tell me about an account that underperformed. What did you do, and what did you tell the client? A good answer is a specific story with a diagnosis (broken tracking, a weak offer, a slow landing page, a budget too thin for the auction), a change, an honest outcome, and an early conversation with the client. A warning sign is no story at all, or blame placed entirely on the client's product or sales team.
• How soon would I hear from you if a KPI moved the wrong way? A good answer is before the monthly report, with a hypothesis and a next step attached. A warning sign is “we review performance monthly.”
• What is your diagnostic order when a paid channel drops? A good answer is a sequence: tracking first, then search terms and match types, then the landing page, then the offer, then budget and bidding. A rough version of that order is in why Google Ads is not working. A warning sign is “we test more creative,” which is a tactic, not a diagnosis.
• When would you tell me to pause or stop a channel? A good answer names a threshold and a timeframe they would act on. A warning sign is that they never would, because stopping a channel reduces their fee.

You are listening for two things: whether the agency has a method, and whether it tells clients bad news early. Both matter more than any single result they mention.

Exit terms and what the agency needs from you

• What is the term of the agreement, and what is the notice period? A good answer is a defined first period with a reason behind it (SEO needs months to show, paid channels need weeks), then month to month with 30 days notice. A warning sign is a long initial term with automatic renewal and a penalty for leaving early.
• What do I get when we part ways? A good answer is a hand-off document, full admin rights on every account, source files, and a final report with open items. A warning sign is silence, or a hand-off that costs extra.
• What do you need from me to do this well? A good answer asks for a decision maker with time each week, access within the first days, feedback from sales on lead quality, and a working offer and website. A warning sign is “nothing, we handle everything,” because no agency can fix lead quality without hearing what sales thinks of the leads.
• What would make you turn down my company? A good answer is an honest list: no budget for media, a website that cannot be changed, no tracking, a sales process that does not call leads back. A warning sign is that nothing would.

If you are still deciding between an agency and hiring in person, the same discipline applies to interviews; how to hire a marketer covers scope, screening and a paid trial task. The comparison of models sits in marketing agency vs in-house.

The same questions for an outsourced marketing department

An outsourced marketing department is judged by the same list, and it should welcome every item on it. Here is how Marketers.com answers, for the record.

• Who does the work: a senior project manager with 15+ years of experience is your single point of contact and builds the team, one vetted marketer or several, matched to your industry and scope. You do not pick people from a list; the project manager does the matching and stays accountable for it.
• Process: it starts with a free marketing analysis delivered as a PDF within 24 hours, then work runs in stages with the project manager setting the scope and approving what goes live.
• Ownership: ad accounts, analytics, domains and content stay in your name.
• Reporting: the project manager sends a monthly report built around the KPIs agreed at the start.
• Fees: billing is monthly and separate from ad spend.

The full process is on how it works, and the model is described on marketing as a service. Whichever route you take, keep the list. Questions to ask a marketing agency are only useful if you write the answers down and hold the provider to them at the 90-day review.

FAQ