Almost every category in the five boroughs is crowded, and the crowding is visible. Walk a block of Court Street in Brooklyn or Amsterdam Avenue on the Upper West Side and you pass several businesses selling nearly the same thing, often with similar serif logos and similar promises of quality. Online it is the same picture, only faster. When everything looks careful and refined, refinement stops being a reason to pick you.
So the real question for a New York company is rarely how the logo should look. It is what you want a busy person to remember about you after a few seconds, and whether your name, your headline and your visual system all point at that one idea. A law practice in the Financial District, a bakery in Astoria and a contractor serving Westchester answer that question differently, but each of them has to answer it in writing before design begins.
The metro is several markets at once
Manhattan buyers, commuters from Hoboken and Newark, families in Queens and Staten Island, and procurement teams upstate or on Long Island respond to different cues. A brand that only speaks to the Manhattan crowd can feel cold in Bay Ridge, and one built for the neighborhood can look small in a corporate pitch. Good branding work maps which of these audiences matter to you and designs for them on purpose.