Few metros put so many similar businesses within walking distance of each other. A diner in Astoria, a boutique accounting practice on Park Avenue South and a moving company in Bushwick all sit next to dozens of rivals who appear in the same search results. When a visitor lands on your site, the back button is one thumb away, and the alternative is usually a block away too.
Density changes what a homepage must do
In a car-based city, people may tolerate a vague homepage because the options are few. Here the first screen has to say what you do, for whom, in which boroughs or towns, and how to reach you. Hours, neighborhood, a tap-to-call link and one clear next step belong above the fold, while the story of the firm can wait further down.
One region, several audiences
The metro stretches from Manhattan into Newark, Jersey City, Long Island and Westchester. A commuter in Hoboken, a family in Staten Island and a procurement lead in a Midtown tower read the same page with different expectations, so navigation and copy are written to let each find their path quickly.